Sometimes, the most responsible decision an IVF professional can make is to say no.

At CanBaby Fertility Consulting in Burnaby, BC, we recently received a surrogacy request from a woman living in Metro Vancouver. She had three frozen blastocysts and a strong desire to become a mother.

She wanted our team to help her find a gestational surrogate.

After reviewing her fertility history, however, we decided not to proceed with surrogate matching under the circumstances she presented.

Our decision had nothing to do with her marital status or her desire to become a parent. Instead, two important concerns shaped our response: the age of her eggs when she created the embryos and the unknown chromosomal status of those embryos.

We also had to consider the health, safety, and interests of any woman who might carry the pregnancy.

This real surrogacy case illustrates why professional fertility consulting involves much more than matching intended parents with surrogates.

Privacy notice: Angela is a pseudonym. We have changed or omitted identifying details to protect the client’s privacy.

Angela’s Surrogacy Request in Vancouver

Angela, a single woman in her early fifties, lives in Metro Vancouver.

She has wanted to become a mother for many years. When she was 44, she underwent IVF treatment at a Vancouver fertility clinic.

During that cycle, doctors retrieved her eggs and fertilized them with donor sperm. The laboratory successfully developed three blastocysts and froze them for future use.

Angela did not undergo preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy, or PGT-A, on those embryos.

Several years later, she contacted CanBaby to explore international surrogacy.

Her plan appeared simple. She already had frozen embryos and wanted a gestational surrogate to carry her baby.

Angela hoped that finding a surrogate would finally allow her to become a mother.

We understood her hopes and respected her determination.

However, our IVF experience raised immediate questions about the reproductive potential of her embryos.

Before discussing surrogate matching, we needed to understand the risks and determine whether the proposed treatment had a reasonable medical basis.

Why Egg Age Matters More Than Current Age

Angela was in her early fifties when she contacted us, but she had created her embryos using eggs retrieved at age 44.

That distinction matters.

In IVF, the age of the egg provider at retrieval strongly influences the likelihood of obtaining chromosomally normal embryos.

Freezing an embryo preserves it for future use, but it does not reverse the biological effects of egg aging.

How Maternal Age Affects Embryo Chromosomes

Human eggs contain chromosomes that must separate accurately during egg maturation.

As women grow older, errors during this process become more common.

These errors can produce embryos with an abnormal number of chromosomes. Fertility specialists call this condition aneuploidy.

An embryo with the expected number of chromosomes is generally described as euploid.

Aneuploidy can prevent implantation, contribute to miscarriage, or cause certain chromosomal conditions in an ongoing pregnancy.

Research consistently shows that embryo aneuploidy increases with maternal age, especially after age 40.

By age 44, women using their own eggs generally face a substantially lower probability of obtaining euploid blastocysts than younger patients.

This does not mean that every embryo created at age 44 has a chromosomal abnormality.

Some women still produce euploid embryos and achieve healthy live births.

Nevertheless, age-related chromosomal risk creates an important challenge when patients have only a small number of embryos.

Why Three Blastocysts May Not Mean Three Strong Chances

Angela had three frozen blastocysts.

For someone who has spent years hoping for a baby, three embryos can represent three precious opportunities.

However, embryo quantity does not necessarily reflect embryo reproductive potential.

An embryo may reach the blastocyst stage and receive a favorable morphological grade while still carrying a chromosomal abnormality.

Embryologists evaluate blastocyst development and appearance, but morphology alone cannot confirm chromosomal normality.

In Angela’s case, all three embryos came from eggs retrieved at age 44.

That fact raised serious questions about their expected prognosis.

We could not determine their individual chromosomal status from her age or embryo count alone.

However, we also could not ignore the substantial age-related risk when considering whether to involve a gestational surrogate.

Why the Absence of PGT-A Results Concerned Us

Angela’s embryos had never undergone PGT-A.

PGT-A examines a small sample of embryo cells to assess chromosome copy number.

The results may help fertility specialists distinguish embryos reported as euploid from those reported as aneuploid or mosaic.

For patients with embryos created at an advanced reproductive age, this information may contribute to discussions about embryo selection and prognosis.

However, PGT-A has important limitations.

It cannot guarantee implantation, pregnancy, or the birth of a healthy child. Testing may also produce inconclusive or complex results.

The American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) explains these limitations in its 2024 committee opinion on PGT-A.

Importantly, ASRM does not recommend routine PGT-A for every IVF patient.

An untested embryo is not automatically unsuitable for transfer.

Likewise, a PGT-A result does not replace a fertility physician’s clinical assessment.

Would Testing Angela’s Frozen Embryos Solve the Problem?

Not necessarily.

Testing previously frozen blastocysts may require the laboratory to warm the embryos, perform a biopsy, and freeze them again.

Each additional laboratory procedure requires careful consideration.

The treating fertility physician and embryology laboratory must evaluate whether testing offers meaningful benefits and whether the embryos can tolerate the process.

In Angela’s situation, we believed a specialist should review her original IVF records before anyone arranged surrogate matching.

That review could consider embryo grades, development history, cryopreservation methods, and the potential value or limitations of further testing.

Our concern was not simply that Angela had skipped PGT-A.

Instead, the combination of advanced egg age, three available blastocysts, and unknown chromosomal status created significant uncertainty about the likelihood of success.

A Healthy Surrogate Cannot Correct an Embryo Chromosome Problem

Many intended parents understandably believe that a healthy gestational surrogate can improve their chances of having a baby.

In some circumstances, that belief has a medical basis.

For example, gestational surrogacy may help patients who lack a functional uterus or have medical conditions that make pregnancy unsafe.

It may also provide an option in selected cases involving serious uterine problems or repeated unsuccessful transfers after appropriate medical evaluation.

However, a gestational surrogate cannot correct chromosomal abnormalities already present in an embryo.

The surrogate provides the uterine environment for implantation and pregnancy.

She does not change the embryo’s genetic composition.

If an embryo has an abnormal chromosome number, placing it in a healthy uterus does not make it euploid.

This was central to our assessment of Angela’s request.

We could arrange discussions about international surrogacy, but we could not assume that surrogate matching would solve the underlying reproductive challenge.

A healthy surrogate cannot guarantee a healthy embryo or a successful pregnancy.

For this reason, we believe intended parents should receive realistic information about embryo prognosis before they commit to a surrogacy program.

Our Responsibility Includes Protecting the Gestational Surrogate

The second reason for our decision involved the surrogate herself.

At CanBaby, we do not view gestational surrogacy as a transaction between a paying client and a woman willing to carry a pregnancy.

A surrogate is an individual who accepts real medical responsibilities and potential risks.

She deserves accurate information, independent decision-making, and appropriate medical care.

Every Embryo Transfer Has a Human Cost

An embryo transfer may appear relatively simple compared with egg retrieval or childbirth.

Nevertheless, the surrogate may need hormonal medication, repeated ultrasound examinations, blood tests, clinic appointments, and changes to her daily routine.

She also invests time and emotional energy in the process.

Even when an embryo fails to implant, the treatment creates a burden.

A failed transfer does not automatically mean that the surrogate suffered medical harm. However, the physical, practical, and emotional demands still matter.

We believe fertility professionals should consider these burdens when recommending treatment.

Miscarriage Can Create Additional Risks

The consequences may become more serious when an embryo implants but the pregnancy ends in miscarriage.

Chromosomal abnormalities are a major cause of early pregnancy loss.

A miscarriage can cause bleeding, pain, emotional distress, and additional medical appointments.

Some patients also require medication or surgical treatment.

A gestational surrogate should not face these risks without a clear explanation of the proposed treatment and its expected prognosis.

Of course, no IVF program can eliminate miscarriage risk.

Even a carefully selected embryo can fail to implant or result in pregnancy loss.

The ethical question is whether the medical team has assessed the available evidence and explained the foreseeable risks before proceeding.

Informed Consent Requires More Than a Signature

The ASRM emphasizes the importance of appropriate medical screening, counseling, and informed consent for gestational carriers.

Its recommendations for practices using gestational carriers address essential clinical and ethical considerations.

A surrogate must understand the proposed treatment and remain free to make decisions about her own healthcare.

Her willingness to participate does not remove the responsibility of the medical team to assess treatment suitability.

For Angela, we could not justify moving directly to surrogate matching without a more complete evaluation of her embryos.

We wanted to avoid exposing a prospective surrogate to medical procedures under a treatment plan whose expected benefits remained highly uncertain.

Why CanBaby Declined the Request

Our decision came down to two professional concerns.

First, Angela’s embryos came from eggs retrieved at age 44. That age carries a substantially higher risk of embryo aneuploidy and a lower probability of obtaining euploid blastocysts.

Second, none of her three embryos had undergone PGT-A, and the information available to us did not establish their individual reproductive potential.

Together, these factors raised serious concerns about unsuccessful transfers and pregnancy loss.

We did not conclude that every embryo was abnormal.

Nor did we conclude that Angela could never achieve a live birth using her own embryos.

Instead, we decided that we would not arrange a gestational surrogate for immediate transfer without further specialist assessment and a clearer clinical rationale.

This decision reflected our professional standards, not a universal medical rule that all untested embryos from older patients must be excluded from surrogacy.

A qualified fertility physician and receiving IVF clinic must ultimately assess embryo suitability.

We also recognized that Angela’s willingness to pay for treatment could not resolve the medical uncertainties.

Her financial resources did not change the embryos’ chromosomal risks.

Likewise, her desire for motherhood did not remove our responsibility to consider a future surrogate’s welfare.

We therefore declined to proceed with her request as presented.

Why IVF Professional Experience Matters in Surrogacy Consulting

CanBaby is not simply an organization that introduces intended parents to overseas surrogacy programs.

Our founder has nearly 20 years of professional experience in embryology and assisted reproductive technology.

That experience shapes our approach to fertility consulting.

An IVF laboratory report contains important details about egg maturity, fertilization, embryo development, blastocyst grading, freezing procedures, and previous treatment outcomes.

Understanding these records helps us ask better questions and recognize when clients may need additional medical advice.

For example, repeated failure to produce blastocysts differs from repeated failure to achieve pregnancy after transferring suitable embryos.

Likewise, a patient with a serious uterine condition faces different challenges from someone whose embryos have a low probability of chromosomal normality.

These differences matter when considering gestational surrogacy.

Our professional experience does not replace a fertility physician’s diagnosis.

We do not claim that an embryologist can determine the exact chance of live birth from a short consultation.

Instead, we use our IVF knowledge to help intended parents understand their records, recognize important uncertainties, and seek appropriate specialist guidance.

Sometimes that process supports moving forward with surrogacy.

Other times, it reveals reasons to reconsider the proposed treatment.

Angela’s case illustrates the importance of that distinction.

Learn more about why intended parents choose CanBaby.

The Advantage of Local Fertility Consulting in Burnaby, BC

CanBaby operates from 9618 Cameron Street, Burnaby, BC, serving intended parents across Metro Vancouver.

Many families who contact us already have experience with local fertility clinics.

Some have frozen embryos in storage. Others have undergone unsuccessful IVF cycles or received medical advice that makes pregnancy difficult or unsafe.

International surrogacy introduces additional questions about embryo transportation, clinical eligibility, legal procedures, and program costs.

We believe local intended parents benefit from having an accessible consultant who understands IVF laboratory procedures and can help coordinate the next steps.

Face-to-Face Consultations Before Major Decisions

Our Burnaby office allows clients to meet with us before committing to an international program.

During consultations, we can discuss their fertility history, explain relevant laboratory terminology, and identify questions for their treating physicians.

Clients can also learn about the structure and limitations of our international surrogacy services.

We do not believe every consultation should end with a signed contract.

Sometimes the best outcome is helping someone understand why another medical assessment should come first.

Support for Families with Frozen Embryos

If you already have embryos stored at a Vancouver-area fertility clinic, the medical and laboratory records can help determine your next steps.

The releasing and receiving clinics must review embryo suitability, consent requirements, and transportation arrangements before any international transfer.

CanBaby can help coordinate these processes when the participating clinics authorize them.

For more information, explore our services for intended parents.

Our related guide, Already Have Frozen Embryos in Vancouver? Your Surrogacy Options, also explains important considerations for families exploring surrogacy with existing embryos.

Could Angela Still Become a Mother?

Absolutely, motherhood may remain possible for Angela.

Our decision to decline immediate surrogate matching did not mean that we believed her dream should end.

Her three embryos might still have reproductive potential.

However, no one could determine their individual chances of success from the limited information available during our consultation.

A reproductive endocrinologist could review her original IVF records and discuss the potential benefits and limitations of further embryo assessment.

If a qualified medical team considers the embryos suitable for transfer, Angela could explore whether gestational carrier treatment is appropriate under a carefully reviewed plan.

She might also consider other reproductive options, including donor-egg IVF, depending on her preferences and medical circumstances.

Each path involves different medical, financial, and personal considerations.

The important point is that Angela deserves realistic counseling rather than promises that no professional can guarantee.

We respect her desire to become a mother.

Our decision reflected concerns about a specific proposed treatment, not a judgment about her worthiness to become a parent.

Ethical Surrogacy Sometimes Means Saying No

Surrogacy involves more than finding someone willing to carry a baby.

It requires medical judgment, informed consent, responsible coordination, and respect for everyone involved.

The intended parent deserves honest information about the probability of success.

The gestational surrogate deserves protection of her health, autonomy, and interests.

Medical professionals must evaluate the proposed treatment and explain its limitations.

At CanBaby, we believe these responsibilities should guide every surrogacy program.

We will not promise that every frozen embryo can produce a baby.

We will not suggest that a healthy surrogate can overcome every fertility problem.

And we will not proceed with surrogate matching when significant medical questions require further assessment.

Angela’s story reminds us that professional integrity sometimes requires a difficult conversation.

Our responsibility is not simply to help clients start a surrogacy journey. It is to help them make informed decisions while respecting the people who may participate in that journey.

That principle guides our work in Burnaby and our international surrogacy coordination services.

Speak with CanBaby Before Starting Surrogacy

If you live in Vancouver, Burnaby, Surrey, Richmond, Coquitlam, or elsewhere in British Columbia, CanBaby can help you explore your fertility and surrogacy options.

Whether you have existing frozen embryos or have experienced repeated IVF failures, your previous medical history deserves careful attention.

Our IVF-experienced team can help you understand the information that matters before pursuing international surrogacy.

We offer local consultations in Burnaby and online meetings for intended parents who prefer to speak remotely.

CanBaby Fertility Consulting

9618 Cameron Street, Burnaby, BC, Canada

Book an In-Person or Online Consultation

Medical disclaimer: This article provides general educational information and does not replace individualized advice from a reproductive endocrinologist, embryology laboratory, or other qualified healthcare professional. The case details have been modified to protect privacy.